Extra: We’re more than a single emotion

(Warning: this post contains thoughts on characters from Chihayafuru and thus might have a light spoiler hidden here and there)

Finding solid female characters in any form of media can be a struggle. But anime is probably one of the more difficult categories. This is in part due to the far slower progress of feminist movements within the country, but the biggest immediate reason likely has to do with the lack of female writers and directors within the industry (not that Hollywood is winning any points in this area either, mind you).
Now this is not to say that men cannot write believable female characters. By no means. It’s just far harder to do so. The same goes the other way, of course. It’s harder for a woman to write a believable male character. The reasoning should be pretty obvious. Writers can write a far more realistic story based on things they are more familiar with rather than things they are not.

Which brings me to the surprise that is Chihayafuru and the females characters found within. Considering that this show is technically labeled as a shoujo title (although it’s also marked with two other major genres), I really wasn’t expecting anything fresh in it’s characters. I’m happy to report that, for the first time in many moons, I was wrong.
So let’s talk about Chihayafuru’s main female characters, shall we?

First up is Chihaya Ayase herself. She’s loud and generally air headed about anything that isn’t Karuta. And thus, right from the start, we see a huge difference in this heroine from other shoujo heroines. She’s legitimately clueless. Honestly. Not just clueless here and there when it’s convenient for the writers. She honestly doesn’t pick up on the feelings of others easily, if at all. Just about the only thing that makes her a shoujo heroine is that she has more than one guy who likes her. But with two full seasons down, she still has yet to even consider having a relationship with anyone outside of Karuta. She’s completely focused on her own passion for this Japanese poetry game and you could say that the game itself is her true love.
This is not to say she’s a horribly absent character emotionally. She’s very kind and compassionate as well. But it takes her longer to pick up other’s emotions and her own usually circle back to, yes, Karuta. She also has a bit of a complex about her older sister, who often gets all the attention in the family. But thankfully, in this area as well she remains unpredictable, for she never holds it against her sister and instead continues to support her despite being largely ignored herself.
Chihaya is not defined by her romantic relationships with the opposite sex either, but by what she truly loves and wants to do with her life (although, comically, she struggles to figure out how to apply her passion to a real life job for her future). She’s a female character that doesn’t need a male character to stand. Her admiration for Akira is tied directly to Karuta and it isn’t until the near end of the second season that the smallest thought that her feelings could be deeper even occur to her. Not that the thought sticks. Karuta still rules her and soon she sees him for what he is to her: a rival in Karuta. That’s all.

Next is Kanade Oe, a very strong female secondary character. Now on the surface it seemed like she might end up as an excuse for a big chested character. And yes, I’ll admit, that trick is played a few times. But not often. In fact, her chest size really isn’t even mentioned for quite some time. But what is mentioned is her own passion, which exists in traditional Japanese clothing and the history surrounding it and classical poetry. Her nerdy knowledge of literature really drew me to her as a character, especially as I’m a literature major myself. And, like Chihaya, she’s devoted to her own passion in life rather than throwing herself at any male character that shows any interest in her. Just like the lead of the show, she isn’t defined by a romantic love interest, but by her goals and passions. Her reveal that she wishes to be a reader rather than just a Karuta player later in the series made me more than a little happy. Finally! A girl with a goal!

This brings me to the last female lead in this show and one that doesn’t appear until season two. Sumire Hanano, who is actually one of the most complex female characters I’ve seen as of late. At first, as usual for many female character introductions these days, I feared she was a stereotypical popular girl type who would end up as little more than a catalyst for furthering the incredibly slow shoujo element to the series. I was wonderfully wrong! This female is very stuck on romance and looking good. Very much so. But she’s realistically written that way. She’s more in love with the idea of love, rather than an actual person. She honestly believes that she needs to fall in love as soon as she can and experience love quickly as beauty fades. She knows youth lasts only a moment and thus flings herself into romance with little thought at all as to the other side’s opinion on that matter. At least, she does at first. Over time, she begins to enjoy other aspects of life and slow, very slowly, allows her makeup covered mask to drop. But her passions and life views are still strongly obsessed with love and romance, compelling her to notice the relationships around her and the poems in Karuta very differently from her comrades.

It’s refreshing to see female characters with personal goals and agendas outside of ordinary romance clichés. Women are not defined by a single emotion: romantic love. Some of us do indeed fall in love. Some of us do not. Some of us don’t even register romantic love as something to think about. Regardless, we’re not simple and should never be written as such. We’re human begins. And humans are always complicated things.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Extras and tagged , , , , , , , , by inrosegalaxy. Bookmark the permalink.

About inrosegalaxy

Raised on everything from Moby Dick to the Star Wars X-Wing books from a young age, it came as no surprise to anyone who knew me that I’d become a literature graduate and avid writer. But my love of a good story wasn’t restricted to the written word in my early years. Star Trek, Mystery Science Theater 3000, and badly dubbed Godzilla flicks helped shape my love of science fiction on screen as well. I wrote my first story while in the second grade. It was a horrifying tale about murdering a fairy-eating dog via a slice of pizza (in my defense, my only exposure to pizza was in the cafeteria and I swear you could legitimately kill someone with those things). I was a special snowflake. Today I write science fiction, fairy tales, Gothic epistolaries, fantasy and anything else that pops into my bizarre and twisted mind. I write new articles for my blog every Tuesday and Thursday. And if you happen to fancy Japanese animation, I also run an anime review blog, RRAR, which updates every Monday.

5 thoughts on “Extra: We’re more than a single emotion

    • I initially didn’t notice too much of a pace difference myself, but that was likely because I was breezing through this show so fast. The second season picks up with the characters’ goals going in different directions and only slowly becoming more unified by the end with the group tournaments. So although it’s logical that different people would have different goals, it did make the show waver a bit during the first half of the second season. I just hope keeping goals straight is a major element of any future installments as diverting too much again might kill off the show’s momentum.

      • I really noticed the pacing because I was watching the 2nd season as it came out on CrunchyRoll.

        The tournament that ends the 2nd season happens at about episode 15 in season 1, so it’s about 60% slower.

  1. Really interesting character analysis! You have yourself a follower :-)

    Oh btw, you mentioned you were surprised at the female characters. I believe the manga author is female, if you didn’t know.

    • Thank you! I hope you like the posts to come as well ^^
      Yes, but even we female authors can (and do) fall for stereotypes. I just recently read a book by a female author and the girls are pretty 2D. Well, nearly everyone is 2D in it, but still. Crying shame.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s